I am 72 years old and currently use a non-smart Nokia phone on Asdaâs pay-as-you-go network. I put Â£10 on it a year ago and still have about Â£3 left, as I only use it for emergencies. My grandkids keep on at me to get a smartphone, but I need one that is unlocked and works with my Asda sim or at least a similar PAYG deal. I already have an Android tablet, but it does need to be connected to wifi, which I have at home. Any suggestions for a cheap smartphone that would be suitable for my needs? Ronald
You donât have any needs, so you really donât need to spend any money on a smartphone. If your grandkids want you to have one, try suggesting that they give you one. They could club together for a Christmas present, but it doesnât even need to be new. I expect many if not most of the people you know have at least one Android phone sitting around in a drawer.
Ask around. Most old Android phones are worth little or nothing. You may well know someone who will give you one.
Failing that, do a regional search on a classified website such as Gumtree, or try Preloved or Second-Hand Phones.com etc. (Caveat emptor: Iâve not used either.) You can also buy second-hand Android phones on Amazon.co.uk and eBay, and probably from local âcash converterâ shops.
Android is now up to version seven, AKA Nougat, although its eighth iteration, Oreo, is round the corner. However, around a third of Android users are still on version six (Marshmallow), while a fifth are on version 5.1 (Lollipop). Roughly as many people are using version 4.4.4 (KitKat) as are on the latest Nougat. Get the newest version you can, while avoiding any sweets or puddings that appear before those, alphabetically speaking (Jelly Bean, Gingerbread etc).
Before you buy a second-hand phone, check its approximate value.
Carphone Warehouse has a trade-in website where you can type in the product name or IMEI and get a price. For example, it will give you Â£10 for a fully-working second-generation Moto G, and nothing if itâs not working or otherwise damaged. (Having the IMEI also means you can check the phoneâs background.)
The second-generation Moto G is still a decent phone with a 5in screen. It was launched in September 2014 running Android 4.4.4 (KitKat), and it can be upgraded to 6.0 (Marshmallow). Depending on the specification, you should be able to get an unlocked one for Â£25 to Â£45.
In any event, avoid smartphones with less than 8GB of storage.
For more advice, see my earlier answer: How should I go about buying a second-hand smartphone?
Cheap new smartphones
Generally, I recommend spending roughly Â£150 to Â£250. In your case, I looked for smartphones that cost under Â£100. The results were mostly Chinese models that Iâve never used or, in many cases, even heard of. It might be worth considering ones with lots of good Amazon reviews, though these phones also seem to have plenty of bad reviews. Examples include the Â£42.89 Doogee X10 (217 five-star reviews; 136 one-star reviews) and the Â£46.99 Padgene Stylish (10 five-star reviews; 9 one-star reviews).
The Oukitel C5 Pro might be worth a punt at Â£69.99 because it handles 4G as well as 3G, and it was selling for Â£255.99 back in August.
The Vodafone E8 (Â£49) and N8 (Â£79) and the Alcatel Pixi 4 (Â£99.99) are well known in the pay-as-you-go smartphone market, and have been quite well reviewed. They often come with drawbacks. For example, you may be obliged to buy a Â£10 âbundleâ â which you cancel then drop after 30 days â and get them unlocked.
On balance, I reckon your best bet is the 4.5in second-generation Moto E for Â£89.99. Itâs a 4G smartphone running Lollipop. Itâs sim-free and unlocked, so there are no hidden charges. If you shop around, you can sometimes get a new one for around Â£70. (In passing, the first-gen Moto E was reviewed here by Samuel Gibbs.)
Asdaâs pay-as-you-go deals were generally very good so thereâs probably not much point in changing. However, if you have a standard sim, it probably wonât fit in your new phone. I assume that if you contact Asda Mobile customer services on 2732, they will send you a new multi-sim so you can pop-out whichever smaller size you need: micro or nano. Make sure Asda understands that you want to keep your existing number.
If you want to switch to a different service, you will need to ask Asda for a PAC (porting authorisation code) to transfer your number.
Unfortunately, most PAYG deals now involve monthly payments. Even Â£5 a month would dramatically increase your costs. However, 1pMobile offers very low prices â 1p a minute, 1p a text, 1p a MB â with Â£10 top-ups that last four months. The total cost would be at least Â£30 a year, but thatâs still cheap for smartphone use.
Alternatively, thereâs FreedomPop, which provides a free mobile phone service. The Basic 200 plan provides 200 minutes of calls, 200 texts and 200MB of data for nothing, over 3âs network, where available. Obviously, FreedomPop wants you to upgrade to its Premium Â£4.99/month or Â£19.99/month services, or use bolt-ons that add to the cost. Readers who have tried the service are welcome to comment below.
Most services require you to use the phone every six months or less or theyâll de-activate the number.
You donât want a smartphone now, but if you had one, you might find it useful. The obvious applications are the built-in camera and music player, and many smartphones still include FM radios. There are also numerous shopping, booking and banking apps that you may already use on your Android tablet.
Do you like walking? If so, you can get maps and directions on your smartphone. Options include Google Maps, HERE WeGo, Navfree and Maverick. Smartphone city maps, transit maps and tourist guides are extremely useful when visiting unfamiliar cities.
Do you use any social networks? Facebook, Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp, Instagram and Skype all work well on Android smartphones. Your grandkids probably use most of these, so a smartphone might help you keep in touch.
Do you want to increase your home security? You can use a smartphone to access surveillance cameras remotely.
Do you want to get more exercise and improve your health? Buy a Fitbit or similar tracker and you can use a smartphone app to count your steps, graph your weight, record your sleep patterns, measure your heart rate, and prompt you to move around if you have been sitting down too long.
Thereâs really nothing wrong with using an old Nokia to make voice calls and send texts. The whole point of having a smartphone is that it can do so much more.
Have you got a question? Email it to Ask.Jack@theguardian.com